SPACE

by Hamza

We will read out the thought experiments at the event, so there is no need to read before you arrive. They are here so that you can read along on your phone, should you wish to :-)

THE SPACE WE NEED

THE SPACE WE TAKE

THE SPAC WE GIVE

THE SPACE WE NEED

Year 34 BC (Before Calamity)

As their spaceship enters within viewing distance of Proxima Centauri, the two astronauts on board do not register the presence of the red dwarf. Captain Creed Callahan and Major Frank Thomas are locked in a heated argument.

Captain Creed Callahan: You're going to doom humanity.

Major Frank Thomas: Mate, humanity doomed itself. I'm just trying to make a burrito.

Creed: With six of the bloody ration packs? Are you trying to feed a whole village?

Frank: You know how hard it is to replace salsa with this space junk?

Creed: Maybe that's because the space junk is meant to keep us alive on the way back? It's not a replacement for your damn salsa!

Frank: Hah! The way back. Mate, what did the ad say when they recruited you? "Looking for the most gullible jackass on planet Earth"

Creed: Nah, just the biggest idiot on this spaceship apparently (He slumps onto a chair, resigned).

Frank: (Pauses and looks across at him). Do you want a burrito?

(No answer)

Frank: Look mate, I've split the rations equally. I'm only eating from my half. If you want to save your damn earth, then good freaking on ya. Just let me be.

Creed: I can't do that.

Frank: What do you mean? Do you have a problem with the split? You can have 60:40. Tell you what, if you tell them I died heroically when you get back, I'll even do 80:20.

Creed: (Stands up again) What is wrong with you?

Frank: Wrong with me? Mate, I'm just done with it, done with all of… whatever this is.

Creed: You don't get to be done.

Frank: Excuse me? The only freaking choice I have left is the way I go out, and I'm not going to let you take that from me.

Creed: You have a responsibility!

Frank: Well turns out that the fate of a planet is too much damn responsibility to place on a person, maybe those freaking geniuses should have thought about that before they screwed up the entire eco-

Creed: To me, asshole. You have a responsibility to me. We were chosen for this together. You and me. How am I going to make it back on my own?

Frank: You can fly this damn thing better than me and I'm meant to be the pilot. I'm not exactly worried for you.

Creed: How can you have been one of the best in the world and still be this thick?

Frank: Look mate, all that best of the best was a lie they fed us. There were fifty other pilots just as good as me, I was just the only one stupid enough to…

Creed: Its four fucking years to get back Frank. I don't give a shit about your pilot skills. I need you. I can’t just make a line halfway through the ship and let you piss away your rations.

Frank: Why the hell not? You know what, why don't you keep the spaceship and I'll just float out the airlock.

Creed: Because, asshole, you won't be the only one of us that dies alone.

The two of them stare at each other quietly, both unsure what to say. In the silence, Frank finally notices the red light of Proxima Centauri bleeding through the windows.

Major Frank Thomas: Is that…?

Captain Creed Callahan: (Looks behind him) Ho…ly… shi…

QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:

  1. How do we know when someone needs space, and when they need us to stay?

  2. How much freedom do we really have when people are depending on us?

  3. Do we have a greater responsibility to the people we know personally than to the world at large?

  4. Would you ever sign up to a mission to travel four years trapped in a small rocket to discover a habitable planet? What if the extra room was the only way to save humanity?

  5. If you found out Frank and Creed had been randomly chosen from amongst a pool of eligible candidates, and not volunteered for the mission, would that change the level of responsibility you see them as having?

  6. Frank asks Creed to pretend he died a heroic death. What does it mean to die a hero?

  7. Can a pair of humans really save an entire planet, or is the idea of relying on heroes inherently dangerous?

By: Hamza, THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS IN PUBS Group Member. You can read more of his writing here.

THE SPACE WE TAKE

Year 5 AC (After Calamity)

Coyote News Host: “Good evening and thank you to our wonderful audience for tuning into the special Launching Day edition of Coyote News. It has not been an easy five years since the Calamity but this historic day is a moment every one of us can celebrate. Nearly 40 years after Thomas and Callahan’s heroic journey marked a path for us all, tonight we will bring you live coverage of the first ever citizen-ship launching towards our new home. But before we can take you live to this momentous occasion, you all better listen up, because here's a message from the Prime Minister.

Prime Minister: Good evening and happy Launching Day. As the first ship takes off, I want to reassure every one of you that no man, woman or child will be left behind. Each digital ID has been assigned a specific launch time and ship over the next year. I know you are all anxious to leave but please be reassured that the flight schedule has been created after an extensive risk assessment, and all decisions were made to ensure your safety. This first month will be critical personnel and private ships only. The hospital ships will all be launching in the second month to minimise the exposure that the most vulnerable are currently facing from Earth’s environment.

For those of you in the overflow housing areas, unfortunately the logistical situation requires larger ships that will be leaving near the end of the year. In the meantime, we must emphasise that you do not leave your designated housing areas even after neighbourhoods around you have been emptied. Remember, the bonds of ownership still apply to keep us from falling into chaos - anyone caught trespassing on private property, even if it is empty, will be reallocated to the prison ship leaving next year.

Please be assured that on arriving at our new destination, each citizen of this nation will be allocated an appropriate living space. I thank you all for your cooperation in this process, and I hope those of you still struggling with the aftermath of the calamity will take solace in the fact that in just a year from now, we will together have begun the journey to having all the space we need in our new home.”

Coyote News Host: Thank you for that very reassuring statement prime minister. It's good to know that the future of humanity is in the best hands. The path to our greatness truly is paved by heroes, not just Thomas and Callahan, but also Brad Bradson, CEO and founder of Edison Engines. And ladies and gentlemen I hope you're excited, because he's right here on our shoooow.

Brad Bradson: Thank you, thank you. What an honour. What a privilege. To serve humanity to the final frontier. There were many who doubted the vision. There were many who doubted the amount of water and space our immense number of testing centres were taking. And you know what I say to them? Haters. Gonna. Hate. Because it's our technology that has enabled the flight of mankind. We have conquered this planet already, and now we go onto the next one. And if there's not enough space there, we’ll go to the one after that. You know what we say, infinity for you and me, that's the Edison Engine guarantee.

And just to prove our commitment to your comfort, for a limited time only we’re launching a deal offering deluxe upgrades to your flight over, completely free of charge. That's right, for absolutely no Earth money you'll get not just a more spacious flight for the next four years, once you get to your new home you will have guaranteed employment with Edison Engines for the 10 years after that. You’ll never have to worry about layoffs again, because it will be completely legally impossible for you to leave the job. And you're going to absolutely love our work culture, we’re all about creating a space where we can Make! Things! Happen! Salvation awaits my friends.

News host: Ladies and gentlemen give it up for Brad Bradsooooon! What an inspiring symbol. Thomas and Callahan would be so proud. Can you imagine what they were thinking when they first laid eyes on our new home? Cos we just know they must have been so excited to blaze this new path for all of us.

Now, here at Coyote News we fundamentally believe in lending a helping hand to the poor and needy. So for our next guest, we’re delighted to welcome the director of renowned charity - the Humane Agenda.

Director of Humane Agenda: Thank you. I'm coming to everyone today with a critical message. While Launching Day is a celebration, it also marks the end of a tragic chapter for humanity. It is our systems of consumption that have led us to the destruction and abandonment of our home. We cannot keep relying on technology to solve the problems it creates, because the same dangerous patterns of disregard for the world around us, are what's going to-

News Host: Cut.

Director: What?

News Host: Sorry honey, that's all the room we had for you on the programme tonight.

Director: No way, after you gave Brad Bradson time for that whole disgusting spiel?

News Host: Right but he paid way more for his slot.

Director: That's not fair, we’re a charity not a mega corporation.

News Host: This is show business baby. You get what you pay for - what could be more fair than that?

QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:

  1. The president says each person will get an “appropriate living space” - what do you think this means? What do you think it should mean?

  2. When we have the space we need, is it unethical to take more?

  3. Do you think technology solves more problems than it creates? Does your answer to this question change if you only consider recent technology, like say the last 10 years?

  4. If technology could genuinely mean we were no longer limited by resources, do you think we would still need to change how we live?

  5. If everyone around you was leaving the place you call home, do you think you’re more likely to be the first to leave or the last to stay?

  6. Under what life circumstances might you consider taking Brad Bradson's deal?

  7. You get what you pay for. What could be more fair than that?

By: Hamza, THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS IN PUBS Group Member. You can read more of his writing here.

THE SPACE WE GIVE

Passages from a Pair of Letters - Year 75 AS (After Salvation, formerly known as After Calamity)

“Dear Sofia,

It’s been a hard 24 hours since I last saw you. I think we were so caught up in the excitement of everything this represents, and the wonderful time we spent together in the last few weeks, that I don't think I even realised what it would actually feel like. I can only imagine it'll be like this last day, but stretched across a lifetime. I know I should be excited, but right now it just feels like loss. I mean it'll have been 3 days by the time this reaches you, so maybe you'll have more perspective. Though it'll be something like 11 days from now when I hear back, so maybe I'll be wiser too. After being so used to having your voice besides me, waiting even 11 days feels like a lifetime.”

“Hey Gustav. I'm not sure about the wisdom. The rocket is still cramped. I miss Frankonia. Not as much as I miss you, naturally. But I’ve realised Frankonia needs you more than I do. Maybe I’m just telling myself that. We made the choice, so why do I feel so trapped within it? I guess I'm not; I could go tell the pilot to turn back around now. They'd probably listen. But I don't.

It'll be weeks before I get your next message right? If it's space that separates us, why does it feel so much like time that keeps getting in the way?

Still yours, in a sense,

Sofia”

LightMail receipt confirmation

Delivered from Frankonia: 82AS

Received in New Creedsville: 84AS

Content:

“Dear Sofia,

How did you all do it so fast? The recruitment offers from New Creedsville must have started being sent just a couple years after you landed? I knew you were good, but setting up a functioning colony on a new planet this quickly is unbelievable. I couldn't be more proud of your conviction in the world you dream of building.

Speaking of dreams, I've had a son. I guess I also haven't told you that I’d met someone. And got married. I'm going to keep writing letters to you of course. Because like I promised, I won't ever stop loving you. I told her before we got married, obviously I had to. She was weirdly supportive about it. I mean she's absolutely wonderful, but I don't think she thinks you're real. I’m not sure if I fully believe it anymore either. I have the photos of course, but I can't remember the scent of the perfume you used to wear. I remember only how it made me feel.

You know, we don't always have to wait for the letters to arrive before we write the new ones? So much has happened in the last four years, it feels so bizarre to be peering through these gaps to catch glimpses of each other's lives.”

LightMail receipt confirmation

Delivered from New Creedsville: 84AS

Received in Frankonia: 86AS

Content:

“Gustav thats so incredible. I know how much bringing new life into the world meant to you. And that you've found someone who understands. I've not been so lucky, I’m afraid. I've fallen both into and out of love since we last spoke.

You're right that four years is a long time. But if we don't wait, and we were sending multiple letters at once, then we'd be replying to all these different versions of ourselves. I love the idea of hearing from you every year. Or maybe even every month. But then I'm not talking to you anymore. We're only ever talking to different versions of each other. I suppose we already are. But at least I can keep track of the version of you I'm loving. Don't worry, I'm not breaking that promise either.

New Creedsville is everything I could have hoped for. But it's not my dream. It felt like it could be different, but just like the stories grandma used to tell us about Earth, it feels inevitable we're going to keep expanding to fill the space available.”

LightMail receipt confirmation

Delivered from Frankonia: 111 AS

Received in New Creedsville: 113 AS

Content:

“Sofia. I know we said we wouldn't double-message. But the doctors were right. She didn't make it. I have to be there for the kids. She was just months away from meeting her first grandchild. I have to carry on everything me and her built, alone.

I really wish I could talk to you right now. You always knew what to say. Maybe this is just the grief talking, but I can't help thinking about that choice we made. About what our lives could have been if we stayed. Of what shape our love might have taken if instead of confining it to a letter every four years, we'd let it blossom. I know we swore we wouldn't say what if. But I need to know, do you really never regret it?”

LightMail receipt confirmation

Delivered from New Creedsville: 113 AS

Received in Frankonia: 115 AS

Content:

“My dear Gustav,

Of course I regret leaving us. Every single day. And to be honest, it comforts me to know that you do too. Even if it is under such shitty circumstances.

I'm so sorry about what you're going through. And I won't tell you not to dwell in the regret, because I know I can't stop myself either. What I do know is - we’d have both regretted it much more if we'd stayed.”

QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:

  1. How does physical distance change the space someone occupies in your life?

  2. When does giving someone space become letting them go?

  3. If messages to someone you cared about took years to arrive, would you write whenever you had something to say or wait until you could respond to what they'd written?

  4. Do you think Sofia and Gustav are being unfair to their new partners by holding onto their love for each other?

  5. How do we make peace with the lives we might have lived?

  6. What do you think Frank and Creed (prompt 1) would have thought about the new colonies being named after them?

  7. Sofia dreams of building a better world for those who will inherit it. Gustav wants to bring people into the world who will grow up knowing they are loved. Which way of caring for those who come after speaks to you more?

  8. Given a similar choice to Sofia and Gustav, would you give up on love to pursue your dreams?

By: Hamza, THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS IN PUBS Group Member. You can read more of his writing here.

THE AUTHOR OF TONIGHT’S THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS

As a usual suspect at TEIP, Hamza spends more time than is reasonable asking why we believe the things we believe, and being suspicious of anyone who claims to be rational.

He works in Public Health, though that's really more of an ideal than a discipline, so he mostly just thinks about whatever societal problem he feels is currently most pressing, and why it has come to be.

Often he writes about them, and on a few rare occasions, even finishes said writing. You can find more of his writing here.

STAY IN THE LOOP

Join the mailing list for event updates, stories, reflections and the occasional invitation.

TEiP Instagram: